Filipino or Indonesian Maid

 compare Filipino and Indonesian maids in language ability, salary, religion, working attitude, personal characteristics and cooking skill.

About 240,000 domestic helpers working in Singapore. Out of these 240,000, nearly half are Indonesian, 70,000 maids are from the Philippine, Myanmar maid and Indian maid makes up almost all the rest.

In this article, we try to compare Filipino and Indonesian maid in a few areas to help the employer make an informed decision in selecting maid.  

The points mentioned are the summary of the general perceptions that we find in online forums, facebook groups as well as views shared by neighbours and friends who have hired maids before, These may not reflect individual maid’s true personal ability or characteristics.

 

Filipino or Indonesian Maid - Salary

In the Year 2017

Indonesian Maid

Filipino Maid

Average Salary

$594

$596

Median Salary

$585

$585

Minimum Salary

$550

$570

 

Filipino or Indonesian Maid - Religion

 

Indonesian Maid

Filipino Maid

Religion

Mostly is Muslim; it is not common to find Christian.

Almost all are either Catholic or Christian.

 

It should be noted that many Indonesian maids can still help their employers handle the pork although they are not allowed to eat pork.

 

Filipino or Indonesian Maid - Language

Language is critical for day-to-day communication. It is good if the maid can speak clear English.

 

Indonesian Maid

Filipino Maid

Language ability

Many new maids have problem in understanding English, they may not be able to understand your instruction. They may not be able to express themselves.

Most Filipino maids are able to understand employers’ instruction and are able to express themselves clearly.

 

Some employers also feedback that their jobs are mostly routine daily task, language ability will become less important once the helpers get used to the regular job.

 

Filipino or Indonesian Maid - Working Attitude

 

Indonesian Maid

Filipino Maid

Working Attitude

(a) Indonesian maids are found to be hardworking.

(b) Maybe because of their language ability, sometimes they are slow to understand your requirement.

(a) Filipino maids are effective in their jobs.  

(b) Many employers find Filipino maids hard to manage as they are too “smart”, they always have trick to get around thing.

 

Filipino or Indonesian Maid - Personal Characteristics

 

Indonesian maid

Filipino maid

Personal characteristics

(a) Many are easy going.

(b) They are generally quite

Introvert.

(a) They are more outgoing. 

(b) Some employers feel they are arrogant and are more demanding.

 

Filipino or Indonesian Maid - Cooking Skill

 

Indonesian Maid

Filipino Maid

Cooking skill

It seems to be a consensus among employers that the Indonesian maids, especially one who is married, can cook well.

With training, the Filipino maids may be able to help you prepare the food.

 

Last, based on a survey conducted by Babyment, maid agency fee need to hire an Indonesian maid is generally different from fee required to hire a Filipino maid. As different maid agencies have a different service fee, we are unable to quantify the difference.

 

Looking For Indonesian or Filipino Maid

You can click Indonesian maid or Filipino Maid to find maid that meets your requirement. 

Share this Article: